The Lower Funnel Trap:
Why Chasing Quick Conversions Is Slowly Killing Your Growth

The Seductive Lie that is “Performance Marketing”

Your attribution model is lying to you. And if you’re making budget decisions based on incomplete data, you’re systematically defunding the very media channels that drive your growth.  

Think about it.  

Here’s a question that should make every marketer pause. If you’re only investing in media that targets people actively shopping right now, then where will your future customers come from?

We call this The Lower Funnel Trap. And, most marketing teams fall right into it. It’s a dangerous belief that capturing ready-to-buy customers is a sustainable growth strategy. But reality tells a different story. This approach leads to a slow and steady march toward irrelevance.

Think about your own media mix. If you’re like most brands, you’re pouring the majority of your budget into lower-funnel tactics like paid search, retargeting, programmatic ads targeting in-market audiences, and conversion-focused social campaigns. Meanwhile, you’re treating upper-funnel media (TV, streaming audio, brand-building creative) as a “nice to have.” It’s also the first to get cut when budgets tighten.

While focusing on the lower funnel feels efficient and smart, you’re actually strangling your pipeline.

The Problem: Traditional Agencies Default to What’s Easy to Measure

This creates three inevitable problems.

1. You’re Not Creating Any Demand

Lower-funnel media only captures existing demand. It doesn’t create future customers. When you focus exclusively on people already in the buying mode, you’re competing with every other brand for the same small audience. As competition intensifies, each customer becomes more expensive to acquire.

2. You’re Making Your Funnel Tighter and Tighter Over Time

Without sustained media investment in higher-funnel channels, future demand doesn’t just quietly dissipate, it evaporates. The brands that’ve invested early in the journey are winning customers long before they ever enter a “buying cycle.”

3. Your Brand Becomes Invisible to Future Buyers

Don’t fixate on in-market buyers. When you ignore the much larger audience still forming preferences, you starve your future demand. Without upper and mid-funnel investment, your pipeline of future customers vanishes.

The Data Shows What Actually Drives Growth

Sales cycles are growing longer across industries. Customers are taking more time to decide. The classic marketing “rule of seven” says that consumers need around seven interactions with your brand before making a purchase. Today’s complex, omnichannel environments may require more touchpoints.

The ROI IMPACT

A 2021 Nielsen study showed the ROI impact of adding upper-funnel media.

How The Lower Funnel Trap Destroys Your Growth

The pattern is predictable and deadly.

You allocate most of the budget to lower-funnel conversion tactics based on what’s easiest to track. At first, everyone focusing on immediate conversions and trackable metrics is seeing results that appear acceptable.

Then the spiral begins.

• Your brand awareness drops as fewer prospects discover you
• Your low-funnel performance deteriorates because fewer people know to consider you when they enter buying mode
• You cut more brand-building media to “focus on performance”
• The cycle accelerates your brand’s decline until consumers simply don’t know you anymore

Harvard Business Review found that brands making the deepest and fastest media cuts during downturns were least likely to outperform competitors once markets recovered. Want more proof? 80% of companies that cut marketing during the last three recessions failed to regain pre-recession sales and profits three years later.

The Strategic Solution: Embrace The Long Funnel

Breaking free from The Lower Funnel Trap doesn’t require guts, it requires a fundamental shift in how you think about media investment.

Invest in Long-Term Trust-Building

Brands must invest in long-term trust-building by showing up across a dynamic media mix with tailored messaging for each media channel, stage of the funnel, and audience segment.

McKinsey research concluded that companies delivering the best end-to-end customer experiences see stronger sales, better retention, lower service costs, and, wait for it, happier employees.

Follow The 60/40 Rule

Research consistently shows brands with longer consideration cycles need approximately 60% of their budget in high-funnel media and brand building, and 40% in low-funnel conversion activities. Most brands do exactly the opposite and then wonder why their performance marketing is becoming less and less effective.

See The Whole Picture

Real attribution doesn’t just track the last click. It maps the entire customer journey, revealing how your media channels work together to drive business results. The customer who converted today may have first encountered your brand three weeks ago on Connected TV, visited your website after seeing a YouTube ad, researched competitors, and finally converted after clicking that “final” paid search link.

Traditional last-click attribution gives 100% of the credit to that final search click and zero credit to the CTV and YouTube ads that actually kickstarted the customer’s journey.

A Very Real Example: How Sit ‘n Sleep Escaped The Trap

During COVID, Sit ‘n Sleep reduced high-funnel brand building by 39% while their competitor invested heavily in awareness and expanded 8x.

In 2022, Sit ‘n Sleep faced an abrupt market contraction due to inflation and escalating interest rates. By 2024, their competitor outperformed them in search volume by 62%.

Wingman Media implemented a full-funnel, integrated strategy that met customers at every stage of the journey. The plan combined brand building through linear and streaming TV, life-event data to target prospects before they begin shopping, competitor-audience targeting with persuasive incentives, and an aggressive search strategy optimized for store visits.

The results:

• Consumer consideration-attributed sales: +123% year over year
• Total sales growth: +30% year over year
• Brand search interest: Returned to 2019 levels, surpassing the competition
• Programmatic ROAS: +72% improvement
• 249% increase in foot traffic from competitor conquest campaigns
• Cost-per-walk-in: 132% decrease

The Bottom Line

We’re not saying that capturing ready-to-buy customers doesn’t matter. It does. But harvesting alone won’t grow your business. You can’t harvest what you never planted.

The brands that will dominate tomorrow are the ones investing in full-funnel media strategies today. While competitors optimize themselves into irrelevance by  chasing only bottom-funnel conversions, you’ll have a complete system that builds awareness, shapes consideration, and converts with efficiency.

The Lower Funnel Trap is just one of five thinking traps quietly undermining growth-minded brands. Each trap has a corresponding power move that offers a clear, strategic shift from reactive thinking to competitive advantage.

READ SIMILAR POSTS